When a business outgrows its bookkeeper and year-end accountant, the next step is usually described as “getting an FD”. Sometimes that’s right. Often, what the business actually needs first is a financial controller, and hiring a director before the numbers are reliable means paying for strategy built on sand.
A simple way to think about it: a financial controller makes sure the numbers are right. A finance director decides what to do with them.
What a financial controller does
The financial controller owns the accuracy and timing of your numbers. Their focus is the last month and the next few: getting the reporting right, on time, every time.
- Runs a reliable month-end and produces management accounts on time
- Builds and maintains the cash flow forecast
- Oversees the bookkeeper or finance team, and checks their work
- Puts controls in place so mistakes and fraud get caught
- Shows which products, jobs or clients actually make money
- Keeps VAT, payroll and year-end on track with your accountant
What a finance director does
The finance director owns the financial plan. Their focus is the next year and beyond: using reliable numbers to make better decisions.
- Turns the numbers into strategy, budgets and scenarios
- Models big decisions: hiring, pricing, investment, new sites or products
- Leads conversations with banks, lenders and investors
- Sits on the board and is accountable for the financial plan
- Prepares the business for growth, investment or sale
The difference at a glance
| Financial controller | Finance director | |
|---|---|---|
| Main question | Are the numbers right, and on time? | What should we do next? |
| Looks at | Last month and the next 13 weeks | The next one to three years |
| Main outputs | Management accounts, cash forecast, controls | Strategy, budgets, scenarios, funding |
| Works most with | Bookkeeper, finance team, accountant | Founder, board, bank, investors |
| Typical moment | Reporting is slow or unreliable | A big decision is coming |
Strategy built on unreliable numbers doesn’t work. If your monthly reporting isn’t solid yet, you probably need a controller before a director.
Signs you need a controller first
- Month-end takes weeks, or doesn’t really happen
- The numbers often change after you’ve seen them
- Cash keeps surprising you
- Nobody can say which parts of the business make money
- Your bookkeeper is good, but nobody checks their work or explains it
If that sounds familiar, the first job is getting management accounts you can rely on and a cash forecast in place. That’s what my Financial Controller package is for.
Signs you’re ready for a director
- Your monthly reporting is reliable and on time
- The questions have moved on to what to do next: whether to hire, raise prices, borrow, expand or sell
- You’re talking to a bank or investors, or expect to soon
- You want someone senior to challenge your plans and share the weight of big decisions
That’s where a fractional finance director comes in: board-level thinking for a few days a month, without a full-time salary. If you’re weighing that up, what a full-time FD really costs compares the two.
And if you need neither yet?
Some businesses have a good bookkeeper and reasonable numbers, but nobody senior to explain what they mean. They don’t need a controller running month-end or a director sitting on the board. They need an experienced eye on the numbers every month and someone to talk them through with. That’s the Finance Partner package: monthly review, a cash flow forecast and a monthly meeting.
How finance support usually grows with a business
There’s no fixed rule, but most founder-led companies follow a similar path as they grow:
- Starting out: a bookkeeper records the transactions and an accountant prepares the year-end accounts and tax returns. The founder looks at the bank balance.
- Growing, around £750k and up: the bank balance stops being a reliable guide. The business needs monthly numbers, a cash forecast and someone senior to explain them. This is where a finance partner or a part-time controller usually starts.
- Scaling up: more staff, more customers, maybe a second site or product. Month-end needs proper ownership and controls, and the bookkeeper needs oversight. A controller earns their place here.
- Big decisions: funding, an acquisition, a new market or a sale. Now the business needs someone to plan, model the options and sit across the table from banks and investors. That’s the director’s job.
Turnover is only a rough guide. A £2m business preparing for investment may need director-level support sooner than a steady £5m business with good reporting. What matters is the questions you’re trying to answer.
Questions to ask before you bring either in
- Can I trust last month’s numbers, and did they arrive in time to act on?
- Do I know what cash will look like in three months?
- Is there a big decision in the next year that I’d like a second senior opinion on?
- Who checks my bookkeeper’s work today?
- How much senior finance time does the business really need: a few days a month, or every day?
If the first two are a “no”, start with the controller work. If they’re a “yes” and the third one is too, you’re probably ready for a director. If you’d like an outside view, the two-minute check asks six questions like these and suggests where to start.
You don’t always have to choose
In a large company, the controller and the director are two different people. In a founder-led business, they often don’t need to be. My Finance Director package includes everything in Financial Controller, so the numbers and the strategy come from the same person. Many businesses start with the controller work, get the foundations right, and add the director role as the decisions get bigger.
Common questions
Is a financial controller more senior than a finance director?
No. The finance director is usually the most senior finance person in the business, and the financial controller often reports to them. In smaller businesses, one person may do both jobs.
What’s the difference between a bookkeeper and a financial controller?
A bookkeeper records the day-to-day transactions. A financial controller makes sure those records are complete and right, turns them into management accounts and a forecast, and oversees the bookkeeper’s work.
Can a financial controller be part-time?
Yes. Many founder-led businesses don’t need a full-time controller, and a part-time or fractional one can run month-end and the forecast in a few days a month.
This article is general information, not advice for your specific situation.
